Home / Substitution Guides / Cream Cheese
Cream cheese is dense, tangy, and holds structure when chilled · which is why cheesecakes set and frostings pipe. Substitutes must be thick enough to hold shape, not just taste right.
Best for: Bagels, frosting, cheesecake · the reliable pick
Cashew- or coconut-oil-based brands set firmest.
Best for: Spreads and no-bake fillings
Not nut-free.
Best for: Nut-free cheesecake fillings
Chill thoroughly; coconut oil provides the set.
For baked cheesecake, only firm-setting substitutes work · soft spreads melt into soup. Look for coconut oil high in the ingredient list, and always chill overnight.
Adapt a recipe free with RecipeFix → · Dairy-Free Recipe Converter · Vegan Recipe Converter · Nut-Free Recipe Converter
A firm store-bought dairy-free cream cheese, used cold, beaten with powdered sugar and a stick-style vegan butter. Soft homemade versions make frosting slide off the cake.
Store-bought dairy-free cream cheese is the closest match, at 1:1. Bagels, frosting, cheesecake · the reliable pick. Cashew- or coconut-oil-based brands set firmest.
Store-bought dairy-free cream cheese (1:1) if you want the closest result, or Cashew cream cheese (soaked cashews + lemon + salt) (1:1) for spreads and no-bake fillings. Which one is right depends on what the cream cheese was doing in the dish.
Related guides: Sour Cream · Heavy Cream · Butter · All guides